DIAPERS all the way. I'v been wearing bambino diapers and nothing is like the thick feeling of a diaper between your legs. People have been talking about the babish feeling, I think diapers are far more babyish either wet or dry. To hear the crinkle of a diaper as you walk and if you mess your diaper, how babyish is that....lol Pull-ups are still a diapers but they are a just in case diaper that says yea I kinda know how to potty but still have a accident now an then so I am protectd. Plus diaper changes are so much easier with diapers than pull-ups. You don't have to disrobe to put a tape diaper on. With pullup diapers, you have to take pants off shoes sometimes and the fit is just not there. With diapers you can get them nice and snug, have the top of the diaper stick out of your pants if you want and talk about exciting when you have people see the top of your diaper sticking out. Diapers all the way......