Skippy or Jiff

[waynecook52]

Skippy or Jiff

[ValentinesStuff]

Skippy

[liljim57]

My first thought was "Which one for stuffing a diaper."                                                                                                                                                                                                             For eating wife uses JIF.

[Crinklz Kat]

Jif (only 1 F).  Always Jif.   Skippy just never tasted right to me.  

[DailyDi]

Reeses (Yes they make a jar peanut butter.) JIF if reeses isn't available.

[tuffy]

Neither.

I put a jar in the grinder, pour peanuts into the hopper and turn it on. When it's done grinding, I remove my jar of peanut butter and pay for it. 

[Rachael-Little]

Jiff for me 

[tigercub59]

Jiff

[DiaperboyEddie12]

I am a skippy fan!

[zzyzx]

Used to be Skippy.

Now use a less known brand that is lower in salt and sugar.

[bbtwin]

Peter pan 

[rusty pins]

Whichever is the lowest price and still tastes good.  I still picture the funny spoof movie "Back To The Beach" where Annette Funicello's kids kept complaining all she ever made for them to eat were Skippy peanut butter sandwiches! 

[oliver d]

Not one of the cannot stand the stuff,the only way I eat peanut butter is in Reese chocolates

[spoonchicken]

10 hours ago, bbtwin said:

Peter pan 

Peed her pants

Ginger or Mary Ann ?

[vvp39]

I don't care for either; they have sugar in them. I was a long-time user of Adams No-stir Crunchy, but they dropped it a few months ago. I reluctantly went to No-stir creamy.

[Lil Leo]

Hiii!

Skippy creamy, Skippy, nothin' but Skippy so help me God.

[le Hollandais]

Smucker's Natural crunchy

[willnotwill]

2 hours ago, le Hollandais said:

Smucker's Natural crunchy

Yep... you gotta stir it up when new, but it's good stuff.

[zzyzx]

12 hours ago, vvp39 said:

I don't care for either; they have sugar in them. I was a long-time user of Adams No-stir Crunchy, but they dropped it a few months ago. I reluctantly went to No-stir creamy.

@vvp39: You hit the brand I switched to (lower sugar and lower salt).  Last time I picked some up I still was able to find the no-stir (no salt added) crunchy, which was my preference.  I'll have to look closer the next time I'm shopping to see what's available now at my grocery store.

[CentralMaDL]

Peter pan

 

[Nyte Kitsune]

Skippy Extra Crunchy, Jif is a little sweeter so its a "If they're out of Skippy", Do occasionally like the old fashioned stir it types for nostalgia but as they have the tendency to go bad I don't typically buy them.

[rusty pins]

On 2/4/2026 at 10:24 AM, spoonchicken said:

Peed her pants

Ginger or Mary Ann ?

Mary Ann!  Dawn Wells was actually a beauty contest winner, Miss Nevada of 1960.

[xSnowVx]

Skippy for crunchy 

Jiff for smooth 

Peter Pan for times I want to feel small. 

[2sail2]

Jiff with "you got your chocolate in my peanut butter".

[FretaBWet]

Peanut Delight Crunchy (Aldi store brand). It tastes like peanut butter but better because it costs less.

Hugs,

Freta