They did not disappoint!
Being a 6'1, 190 pound male with a 39'' waist, I did not expect even the L/XL to fit well, let alone hold any wetting/mess. But I wanted a diaper that had a smaller profile then say the Abena M4s, so spent a few days or so figuring out what I should get. Found a few threads from a few years ago about goodnights L/XL fitting decent, but still wasn't convinced. Then I remembered a known ABDL woman who had 37-39 waist, so saw she could fit them OK...I figured if she could with a comparable waist size, surely I can?
Ordered a pack of girls goodnights (Male tuck in, so made sense to me to get the lower padding), and tried them on...Fit perfectly well right off the bat. Figured I tried to see how well they hold a wetting (Few mentioned that flooding would be a major issue) and a messing. They held up quite well with both of those (changed out of the first one after those 2 quick tests). I then decided to see if I can sleep in one, as with a diaper like Abena M4, its too bulky for me to sleep comfortably. So gave that a try, fell asleep almost instantly and woke up 8.5 hours later, felt pretty good considering.
Safe to say, I found a new favorite diaper...